
Vivian Baumgard, an 8-year-old from Minnesota, faced a severe narrowing of her aortic valve that normally would require a valve replacement. Instead, a surgeon at the Mayo Clinic repaired her native valve, allowing the original tissue to keep working normally. The case attracted attention because preserving a child’s own valve is still uncommon in pediatric cardiac surgery.
Diagnosis and decision to operate
A heart murmur was first heard when Vivian was an infant, and doctors initially believed the sound would disappear as she grew. The murmur continued to be audible at regular check-ups, prompting her pediatrician to refer her to the Mayo Clinic for a more detailed assessment.
Advanced imaging performed at the clinic revealed an abnormally formed aortic valve. The scans showed distorted cusps and a ring of fibrous tissue that narrowed the opening to a degree that impeded blood flow. By the time she turned eight, the narrowing had progressed to a point where surgery was deemed necessary to prevent further heart damage.
Why repair instead of replace
Replacing a child’s aortic valve with a prosthetic device often leads to additional operations later in life because the artificial part does not grow with the patient. Moreover, many prosthetic valves require lifelong blood-thinning medication to avoid cloting, which adds a permanent medical burden.
Dr. Igor Konstantinov, a cardiovascular and transplant surgeon, explained that “It’s a very delicate balance, particularly in a child.” He noted that repairing a child’s native aortic valve, by contrast, preserves the heart’s natural anatomy and can spare the child from future operations.
Surgical approach
Using high-resolution imaging, the pediatric cardiology team constructed a three-dimensional model of Vivian’s valve. The model, printed from the imaging data, let the surgeons examine the exact shape of the valve and plan each step of the repair with precision.
Related Post: Mayo Clinic works to increase donor organs
Surgeons, anesthesiologists, and intensive-care specialists gathered around the model and discussed the best strategy. Their collaborative review ensured that every member of the operating team understood the unique challenges presented by the malformed valve.
During the operation, Dr. Konstantinov removed the obstructive tissue that lay beneath the valve leaflets. He also cleared the excess fibrous overgrowth, which restored the ability of the delicate cusps to open and close freely.
Outcome and future outlook
Immediately after the procedure, the repaired valve appeared “essentially normal,” opening and closing without any detectable leakage, according to Dr. Konstantinov. He expressed confidence that Vivian would not need another valve operation in the future.
Vivian’s mother, Brooke Baumgard, said the family feels “very fortunate” and hopeful that her daughter can avoid additional heart operations as she grows. Brooke added that the successful repair has given the family a sense of relief and optimism about Vivian’s long-term health.
Two weeks after the surgery, Vivian was cleared by the cardiology team to resume normal activities. She returned to biking, basketball, gymnastics, and swimming.
Dr. Konstantinov, who joined the Mayo Clinic in spring 2026, aims to train other surgeons in complex aortic valve repairs. He is developing a curriculum to teach the valve-preserving technique to colleagues across the country, expanding access to this option for children of all ages who face similar heart conditions.