Senior living marketers adapt as AI changes prospect research - ai prospect research
Claiborne Senior Living’s COO Brooke Saxon-Spencer highlights AI’s growing role in shaping family decisions before community visits.

Senior living operators now face a fundamental shift: families researching senior communities no longer handle through websites to gather information. This development has led to a rise in what operators call “zero-click move-ins”—prospects who arrive at communities already informed, and sometimes carrying preconceptions formed by AI-generated summaries.

Brooke Saxon-Spencer, chief operating officer of Claiborne Senior Living, describes this change as a transformation in the nature of first interactions. “The first conversation is less ‘tell me about your community’ and more ‘here’s what I heard: is it true?'” she said. Sales teams must now shift from introducing themselves to validating the information prospects have already received. This forces operators to rethink how they measure leads, nurture prospects, and establish credibility before families even visit a community.

AI Overviews Kill Traditional Website Leads

The adjustment begins with tracking and measurement. Traditionally, providers relied on website traffic, form submissions, and search analytics to identify leads. Now, AI tools deliver answers without directing users to a provider’s site. The Arbor Company observed a decline in website-generated leads following Google’s launch of AI Overviews in 2024, even as overall lead volume remained stable. In response, Mary Cate Spires, the company’s vice president of marketing and digital strategy, updated its Google Business Profile to ensure AI tools could access accurate, current information.

Watermark Retirement Communities encountered a similar issue: while direct referrals from AI searches stayed low, families arrived further along in their decision-making process. Jamison Gosselin, the company’s vice president of marketing and communications, noted that the organization is adjusting its Google ad strategy by shifting budgets away from generic, high-cost keywords.

Related Post: Senior Housing Sales Span Florida, South Carolina, and Michigan

Economic pressures further complicate the situation. Claiborne reported rising costs per click and lead, alongside less predictable volume from traditional marketing channels. Jason Kohler, executive vice president of senior living at Beztak, confirmed that while AI visibility does not automatically improve lead quality, it also does not guarantee more move-ins. “Our objective isn’t simply to generate more leads,” Kohler said. “It’s to generate more qualified opportunities that result in occupancy.”

To adapt, operators are overhauling their digital strategies. Claiborne now provides highly detailed community information—care models, memory care floor plans, and included amenities—tailored to the specific questions families ask AI tools. “We’re writing for the questions families actually ask, not for keywords,” Saxon-Spencer added. The Aspenwood Company has developed conversational educational content on care types, pricing, and transition processes, while collaborating with the University of Texas at Austin to study how generative AI influences prospect perceptions.

Answer Engine Optimization Redefines Content Strategy

Technical adjustments are equally critical. Watermark enhanced its website schema to help AI systems better interpret its data. Kohler emphasized that Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) extends beyond keywords and blog posts; it requires content structured for both human and AI consumption. “Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) is not simply adding keywords or creating more blog posts,” Kohler added. “It’s making content useful, understandable and credible to both consumers and AI systems.”

Resident reviews and real experiences are emerging as key factors in this shift. Christy Van Der Westhuizen, senior vice president of sales and marketing at Jaybird Senior Living, highlighted that no marketing effort can replace the impact of authentic resident feedback. “We can invest all the money in the world in marketing, but what residents and families say about their experience carries tremendous weight,” Van Der Westhuizen said.

Related Post: Senior Care Groups Embrace New Ideas

Faster Responses, Smarter Spending Boost Conversions

Claiborne has implemented a contact center and AI-powered after-hours support to respond more quickly to prospects. In a pilot program, the company reached 74% of families within 18 days of their tour, with a median decision timeline of just 18 days. Watermark is reallocating sales budgets from low-performing ads to website enhancements, local reputation building, and video production. Aspenwood, now operating at full occupancy with waitlists, has stopped spending on paid search campaigns after changes to the company’s website, though paid advertising still plays an important role.

Beztak and Jaybird are prioritizing results-oriented spending, treating AEO as a supplement, not a replacement, for traditional lead generation. The core challenge remains connecting AI-driven discovery to actual move-ins. Aspenwood spent six months refining how lead sources integrate into its CRM, while Claiborne now tracks “AI tool” as a separate lead category.

Resident experiences and third-party reviews are becoming central to AI-driven decision-making. Van Der Westhuizen emphasized that authentic resident feedback, particularly regarding dining, care quality, and community activities, now carries more weight in AI-generated responses. Operators are investing in structured review systems that highlight specific details, such as meal satisfaction or staff responsiveness, to ensure AI tools reference verifiable, positive insights.